After the revelation of The Dark Knight, here is Watchmen, another bold exercise in the liberation of the superhero movie. Its a compelling visceral film sound, images and characters combined into a decidedly odd visual experience that evokes the feel of a graphic novel. It seems charged from within by its power as a fable; we sense its not interested in a plot so much as with the dilemma of functioning in a world losing hope.
That world is America in 1985, with Richard Nixon in the White House and many other strange details; this America occupies a parallel universe in which superheroes and masked warriors operate. The film confronts a paradox that was always there in comic books: The heroes are only human. They can only be in one place at a time (with a possible exception to be noted later). Although a superhero is able to handle one dangerous situation, the world has countless dangerous situations, and the super resources are stretched too thin. Faced with law enforcement anarchy, Nixon has outlawed superhero activity, quite possibly a reasonable action. Now the murder of the enigmatic vigilante The Comedian (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) has brought the Watchmen together again. Who might be the next to die?
The Comedian, in a gravelly film noir voice-over, narrates from somewhere beyond the grave. Thats always an intriguing strategy, leading us to wonder if the narrator is really dead. The Comedian must be dead (or maybe not) after falling from a high skyscraper window, and he has a detached perspective on the events in the story, a certain fatalistic realism.
Super status doesnt free the other characters so much as limit them. Dr. Manhattan (Billy Crudup), the only one with superpowers in the literal sense, lives outside ordinary time and space, the forces of the universe seeming to coil beneath his skin. Ozymandias (Matthew Goode) is the worlds smartest man. The Nite Owl (Patrick Wilson) is a man isolated from life by his mastery of technology. Rorschach (Jackie Earl Haley) is a man who finds meaning in patterns that may exist only in his mind. And Silk Spectre II (Malin Akerman) lives with one of the most familiar human challenges, living up to her parents, in this case the original Silk Spectre (Carla Gugino).
The mystery of The Comedians death seems associated with a plot to destroy the world. The first step in the plot may be to annihilate the Watchmen, who are All That Stand Between, etc. It is hard to see how anyone would benefit from the utter destruction of the planet, but remember that in 1985 there was a nuclear standoff between the U.S. and the U.S.S.R. that threatened exactly that. Remember Better Red Than Dead? There were indeed cold warriors who preferred to be dead rather than red, reminding me of David Merricks statement: Its not enough for me to win. My enemies must lose.
In a cosmic sense it doesnt really matter who pushed The Comedian through the window. The Watchmen and their special gifts are all the better able to see how powerless they really are, and although all but Dr. Manhattan are human and back the home team, their powers are not limitless. Dr. Manhattan, existing outside time and space, is understandably remote from the fate of our tiny planet, although perhaps he still harbors some old emotions.
Those kinds of quandaries engage all the Watchmen, and are presented in a film experience of often fearsome beauty. It might seem improbable to take seriously a naked blue man, complete with discreet genitalia, but Billy Crudup brings a solemn detachment to Dr. Manhattan that is curiously affecting. Does he remember how it felt to be human? No, but hum a few bars…. Crudup does the voice and the body language, which is transformed by software into a figure of considerable presence.
Watchmen focuses on the contradiction shared by most superheroes: They cannot live ordinary lives but are fated to help mankind. That they do this with trademarked names and appliances goes back to their origins in Greece, where Zeus had his thunderbolts, Hades his three-headed dog, and Hermes his winged feet. Could Zeus run fast? Did Hermes have a dog? No.
That level of symbolism is coiling away beneath all superheroes. What appeals with Batman is his humanity; despite his skills, he is not supernormal. Watchmen brings surprising conviction to these characters as flawed and minor gods, with Dr. Manhattan possessing access to godhead on a plane that detaches him from our daily concerns indeed, from days themselves. In the films most spectacular scene, he is exiled to Mars, and in utter isolation re-imagines himself as a human and conjures (or discovers? Im not sure) an incredible city seemingly made of crystal and mathematical concepts. This is his equivalent to 40 days in the desert, and he returns as a savior.
The film is rich enough to be seen more than once. I plan to see it again, this time on IMAX, and will have more to say about it. Im not sure I understood all the nuances and implications, but I am sure I had a powerful experience. Its not as entertaining as The Dark Knight, but like the Matrix films, LOTR and The Black Knight, its going to inspire fevered analysis. I dont want to see it twice for that reason, however, but mostly just to have the experience again.